Please be aware that you are viewing our Papa Gio’s at Cherokee Lakes Plaza location. We are conveniently located near the intersection of Ball Park Rd and Augusta Hwy (US 1). In the same plaza as Larry’s Giant Subs.

WE ARE NOW OPEN!!

Our newest location located in the Cherokee Lakes Plaza where All Star Pizza formally was is now open!!

View Our Menu

Order Your Meal Online

ORDER FROM MENUFY ORDER FROM GRUBHUB

ORDER FROM SLICE

*Prices subject to change without notice

Come hang out and watch your favorite football games on out patio and enjoy some great specials

Call or stop in to find out about our specials

Customer Reviews

Jodi Gammell

Check Us Out on Facebook

What people are saying..

Melanie Wolgamott Williamson

“Awesome atmosphere,service, and food is off the chain…I had a slice of the white pizza called “Bianca” style I think & it was fabulous….can’t wait to come back for date night and try the chicken marsala!!!!!”

Gloria Moran Stewart

"Delicious Greek Salad and the very best cheesy breadsticks ever! Hubby really enjoyed his meal too! Much better than anything where we live! We even ordered more breadsticks to enjoy at home! When we get back over that way, you will see us again. Thanks for such good food and friendly service!! Wish you had a location near Leesburg, FL. (Hint, hint)"

Judy Gerity

“I have eaten at Papa Gios three times now and I have chosen something different everytime to eat. I have not had an issue with anything on the menu, it is all delicious. Great atmosphere and everyone is attentive to you.”

Donna Riddell

"Delicious pizza.....and they give you alot of garlic knots too...good service too."

Liz Conner-Mazzullo

"The best of NY in the south....actually went home a few months ago, home as in NY, had pizza and I have to say, papa gios was 10 times better!! The tiramisu, amazing! Next up? CANOLLI!!!"

Heidi Sanchez

"Friday Night is pizza night for me. My favorite pizza place!"

Sunshine Pagan

"5 Stars for real. We are Nyers and this is the spot. So excited, so many places have let us down. Not Papa Gio's this is our new spot. Bravo!"

Stephanie Lynam

"OMG !!!! THE MEATLOVERS ...FAHGETABOUTIT !!!!! The sauce ,perfection .The crust, not to thin not to thick . The cheese and meat , very generous , Love ,love love"

Kim Oakley Case

"Wow! I had the Italian sausage and pepperoni pizza...sooo good! Beautiful interior. And the cannoli...mmmmmm."

Jocelin Mazzullo

"Had a slice of the tomato pie. Everyone come check it out it's amazing."